5

The Family

The people the documents touch, and the three documents themselves, in full.

The Birthplace on Henley Street, Stratford-upon-Avon: the timber-framed main house and, at the left, the lower western cottage.
The Birthplace, Henley Street, Stratford-upon-Avon. The lower cottage at the left is the western house where Joan Hart lived as a widow from 1616 to 1646 and where the Testament was found in the roof. The frontage is the 1857 to 1864 restoration.habiloid, 2015-10-17. Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 2.0.

John Shakespeare

Glover and wool dealer. Bailiff 1568. Died 1601.

Ale-taster 1556, constable 1558, chamberlain 1561, alderman 1565, bailiff and justice from 1 October 1568, chief alderman 1571. As chamberlain he recorded 2s for “defasyng ymages in ye chapell” (1563/64) and 2s for “takynge doune ye rood loft” (1564/65). Exchequer prosecutions for usury and illegal wool dealing from 1569 to about 1583. Stopped attending the council from 1577; removed as alderman 6 September 1586 because he “dothe not Come to the halles when they be warned”. Named in the 1592 certificate among nine who “come not to church for fear of process for debt”. Granted arms 1596, exemplified 1599. Nothing records him refusing anything, and nothing records him swearing the Oath of Supremacy the law required of a bailiff; that gap is real.

Mary Arden

Youngest of eight daughters. Married about 1557. Buried 9 September 1608.

Robert Arden’s will of 24 November 1556 left her “all my lande at Willmecote cawlide Ashbyes” and named her co-executor. She bore eight children, signed with a mark (a horse seal in 1579), and left no record beyond deeds and her burial. The “conspicuously Catholic” reputation attaches to Park Hall; the link to Wilmcote runs through a 1501 Snitterfield deed and a claim of second-cousinage, and the College of Arms struck out the Park Hall coat in 1599.

Joan Shakespeare Hart

Baptised 15 April 1569. Buried 4 November 1646.

Married William Hart, hatter, about 1599; he was buried 17 April 1616, a week before her brother. William’s will gave her £20, his clothes and the right to live in the Henley Street property. She lived as a widow in the western cottage from 1616 to 1646, which is where the Testament was found in the roof. Her public record is Church of England throughout. Steggle’s 2024 article makes her the likeliest testator. Only seven surviving documents from her lifetime name her.

Susanna Hall

Baptised 26 May 1583. Died 11 July 1649.

Cited 5 May 1606 for not receiving Easter communion, with about twenty others; “dismissa”. Married the physician John Hall on 5 June 1607. The Halls won a slander suit against John Lane at Worcester in 1613. Licensed a seat in Holy Trinity “for hearinge divine service and Sermons” in 1633. Her epitaph: “Witty above her sexe, but that’s not all, Wise to salvation was good Mistris Hall.” Bearman calls Hall “Protestant, though not Puritan, in his later career”; the Birthplace Trust says Susanna “appeared to have Roman Catholic sympathies”. Her 1606 motive is unknown.

Judith Quiney

Baptised 2 February 1585. Died 1662.

Twin of Hamnet. Married Thomas Quiney, vintner, on 10 February 1616, in Lent, without the licence the season was thought to need; the couple were summoned to the Worcester court, and Quiney was excommunicated for not answering. On 26 March 1616 Quiney admitted “carnal copulation” with Margaret Wheeler, buried with her child eleven days earlier. Shakespeare had re-signed his will the day before, with changes protecting Judith’s portion. Probably illiterate; she signed a 1611 deed with a mark. Nothing in the record touches her religion.

Hamnet Shakespeare

Baptised 2 February 1585. Buried 11 August 1596, aged 11.

The register reads “August 11 Hamnet filius William Shakspere”. Cause of death unknown. Whether his father attended is unknown; the company may have been touring Kent. The reading that a father who buried a son in 1596 and a father in 1601 wrote a play about a dead father who asks to be remembered is a legitimate dramatic premise and not a documented fact; most scholars reject it as biography.

Hamnet and Judith Sadler

Stratford baker and his wife. Godparents to the twins, almost certainly.

Both cited for non-reception of communion in 1606, in the same sweep as Susanna. Sadler witnessed a 1598 conveyance and the 1616 will, and received a ring bequest interlined over the struck-out Richard Tyler. The primary 1606 list was not seen for this file; the citation is widely reported.

William Reynolds

Stratford landowner. Ring legatee, 1616.

Jailed in Warwick for recusancy in autumn 1613; a letter of 2 October 1613 reports William Slaughter securing his release on bail. His parents appear on recusancy lists. Pearce’s suggestion that Shakespeare bailed him out “cannot be proved”, as Pearce himself says. The 1613 imprisonment is cited at second hand and is checkable.

Richard Davies, the witness

Anglican clergyman. Rector of Sapperton from 1695; Archdeacon of Coventry. Died 1707 or 1708.

Inherited William Fulman’s biographical collections at Fulman’s death in 1688 and filled Fulman’s blank Shakespeare entry around 1690. The note holds the deer-poaching story, the “Justice Clodpate” and “three louses rampant” jokes, the death date, the gravestone curse, and the closing clause. A “c. 1660” date that circulates cannot be right. His source is unknown.

The Guild Chapel, Stratford-upon-Avon, from Chapel Lane: battlemented nave, north porch and west tower, with the Guildhall range beyond.
The Guild Chapel of the Holy Cross, Church Street, Stratford-upon-Avon, with the Guildhall and schoolroom range beyond the tower. John Shakespeare, as chamberlain, recorded the payment for limewashing its images in 1563/64.Rude Health, 2012-10-16. Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 2.0.
Glebe Farm at Wilmcote, a brick-encased timber-framed farmhouse, identified since 2000 as Mary Arden's childhood home.
Glebe Farm, Wilmcote, the house identified since 2000 as Mary Arden’s. The building long shown under her name is Palmer’s Farm next door.Elliott Brown, 2013-02-02. Wikimedia Commons. CC BY 2.0.
An engraving of the Henley Street houses in 1769, a long timber-framed range with the western cottage at the left, before the Victorian restoration.
The Henley Street houses in 1769, drawn by Richard Greene and engraved by Benjamin Cole for the Gentleman’s Magazine: the earliest printed view, showing the main house and the western cottage as separate fronts before the restoration.Drawn by Richard Greene, engraved by Benjamin Cole, for the Gentleman's Magazine, 1769. Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.
The row of family grave slabs in the chancel of Holy Trinity, Stratford, with the church's labels.
The family graves in the chancel of Holy Trinity: Anne, William, Thomas Nash, John Hall and Susanna Hall, whose epitaph reads Wise to salvation.Len Williams, 2012-10-15. Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 2.0.
A 1793 engraving of Holy Trinity Church, Stratford, seen from the river.
Holy Trinity Church from the water, engraved by Thomas Medland after T. Thornton, 1793.Thomas Medland, after T. Thornton; scan by the Yale Center for British Art, 1793. Wikimedia Commons. CC0.
George Vertue's 1737 pen sketch of New Place, Stratford: a gabled timber-framed front with rows of windows.
New Place, Stratford, as sketched by George Vertue in 1737. The house was demolished in 1759; this is the only picture of it.George Vertue, 1737. Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.

Document A. The Spiritual Testament, as Malone printed it in 1790

Malone printed the body (Article III from mid-sentence through XIV and the close) at pages 162 to 166 of his 1790 edition, from the five leaves he held. He printed Articles I, II and the opening of III at pages 330 and 331, from a copy John Jordan supplied. Malone described the leaves he held: “The five leaves which were sent to me were very small, tacked together by a thread, the size the eighth part of a sheet.” The spelling below is Malone’s; long s is normalised.

Page 330 of Malone's 1790 edition, where Articles I and II of the Testament are printed from John Jordan's copy.
Malone, 1790, page 330: Articles I and II, printed from the copy John Jordan supplied. Malone never saw this leaf.Edmond Malone, 1790. Internet Archive. Public domain.
Page 331 of Malone's 1790 edition, the end of Jordan's copy of the first leaf.
Malone, 1790, page 331: the end of Jordan’s leaf.Edmond Malone, 1790. Internet Archive. Public domain.
Page 162 of Malone's 1790 edition, where the printed text of the Spiritual Testament begins mid-sentence at Article III.
Malone, 1790, page 162: the body of the Testament begins, from the five leaves he held, at “at least spiritually”.Edmond Malone, 1790. Internet Archive. Public domain.
Page 163 of Malone's 1790 edition, Articles IV to VII of the Testament.
Malone, 1790, page 163.Edmond Malone, 1790. Internet Archive. Public domain.
Page 164 of Malone's 1790 edition, Articles VII to X of the Testament, naming Saint Winefride.
Malone, 1790, page 164.Edmond Malone, 1790. Internet Archive. Public domain.
Page 165 of Malone's 1790 edition, Articles XI to XIII of the Testament.
Malone, 1790, page 165.Edmond Malone, 1790. Internet Archive. Public domain.
Page 166 of Malone's 1790 edition, the close of the Testament.
Malone, 1790, page 166: the close of the Testament.Edmond Malone, 1790. Internet Archive. Public domain.
Supplied by John Jordan in 1790; Malone never saw this leafI.

In the name of God, the father, sonne, and holy ghost, the most holy and blessed Virgin Mary, mother of God, the holy host of archangels, angels, patriarchs, prophets, evangelists, apostles, saints, martyrs, and all the celestial court and company of heaven, I John Shakspear, an unworthy member of the holy Catholick religion, being at this my present writing in perfect health of body, and sound mind, memory, and understanding, but calling to mind the uncertainty of life and certainty of death, and that I may be possibly cut off in the blossome of my sins, and called to render an account of all my transgressions externally and internally, and that I may be unprepared for the dreadful trial either by sacrament, pennance, fasting, or prayer, or any other purgation whatever, do in the holy presence above specified, of my own free and voluntary accord, make and ordaine this my last spiritual will, testament, confession, protestation, and confession of faith, hopinge hereby to receive pardon for all my sinnes and offences, and thereby to be made partaker of life everlasting, through the only merits of Jesus Christ my saviour and redeemer, who took upon himself the likeness of man, suffered death, and was crucified upon the crosse, for the redemption of sinners.

II.

Item, I John Shakspear doe by this present protest, acknowledge, and confess, that in my past life I have been a most abominable and grievous sinner, and therefore unworthy to be forgiven without a true and sincere repentance for the same. But trusting in the manifold mercies of my blessed Saviour and Redeemer, I am encouraged by relying on his sacred word, to hope for salvation and be made partaker of his heavenly kingdom, as a member of the celestial company of angels, saints and martyrs, there to reside for ever and ever in the court of my God.

III.

Item, I John Shakspear doe by this present protest and declare, that as I am certain I must passe out of this transitory life into another that will last to eternity, I do hereby most humbly implore and intreat my good and guardian angell to instruct me in this my solemn preparation, protestation, and confession of faith, at least spiritually,

The join. Jordan’s copy ends at “at least spiritually”. The leaves Malone held begin at the same words. Everything above this line rests on Jordan alone.

The five leaves Malone heldIII. (continued)

* * * * at least spiritually, in will adoring and most humbly beseeching my saviour, that he will be pleased to assist me in so dangerous a voyage, to defend me from the snares and deceites of my infernall enemies, and to conduct me to the secure haven of his eternall blisse.

IV.

Item, I John Shakspear doe protest that I will also passe out of this life, armed with the last sacrament of extreme unction: the which if through any let or hindrance I should not then be able to have, I doe now also for that time demand and crave the same; beseeching his divine majesty that he will be pleased to anoynt my senses both internall and externall with the sacred oyle of his infinite mercy, and to pardon me all my sins committed by seeing, speaking, feeling, smelling, hearing, touching, or by any other way whatsoever.

V.

Item, I John Shakspear doe by this present protest that I will never through any temptation whatsoever despaire of the divine goodness, for the multitude and greatness of my sinnes; for which although I confesse that I have deserved hell, yet will I stedfastly hope in gods infinite mercy, knowing that he hath heretofore pardoned many as great sinners as my self, whereof I have good warrant sealed with his sacred mouth, in holy writ, whereby he pronounceth that he is not come to call the just, but sinners.

VI.

Item, I John Shakspear do protest that I do not know that I have ever done any good worke meritorious of life everlasting: and if I have done any, I do acknowledge that I have done it with a great deale of negligence and imperfection; neither should I have been able to have done the least without the assistance of his divine grace. Wherefore let the devill remain confounded; for I doe in no wise presume to merit heaven by such good workes alone, but through the merits and bloud of my lord and saviour, jesus, shed upon the crose for me most miserable sinner.

VII.

Item, I John Shakspear do protest by this present writing, that I will patiently endure and suffer all kind of infirmity, sickness, yea and the paine of death it self: wherein if it should happen, which god forbid, that through violence of paine and agony, or by subtility of the devill, I should fall into any impatience or temptation of blasphemy, or murmuration against god, or the catholike faith, or give any signe of bad example, I do henceforth, and for that present, repent me, and am most heartily sorry for the same: and I do renounce all the evill whatsoever, which I might have then done or said; beseeching his divine clemency that he will not forsake me in that grievous and paignefull agony.

VIII.

Item, I John Shakspear, by virtue of this present testament, I do pardon all the injuries and offences that any one hath ever done unto me, either in my reputation, life, goods, or any other way whatsoever; beseeching sweet jesus to pardon them for the same: and I do desire, that they will doe the like by me, whome I have offended or injured in any sort howsoever.

IX.

Item, I John Shakspear do heere protest that I do render infinite thanks to his divine majesty for all the benefits that I have received as well secret as manifest, & in particular, for the benefit of my Creation, Redemption, Sanctification, Conservation, and Vocation to the holy knowledge of him & his true Catholike faith: but above all, for his so great expectation of me to pennance, when he might most justly have taken me out of this life, when I least thought of it, yea even then, when I was plunged in the durty puddle of my sinnes. Blessed be therefore and praised, for ever and ever, his infinite patience and charity.

X.

Item, I John Shakspear do protest, that I am willing, yea, I doe infinitely desire and humbly crave, that of this my last will and testament the glorious and ever Virgin mary, mother of god, refuge and advocate of sinners, (whom I honour specially above all other saints,) may be the chiefe Executresse, togeather with these other saints, my patrons, (saint Winefride) all whome I invocke and beseech to be present at the hour of my death, that she and they may comfort me with their desired presence, and crave of sweet Jesus that he will receive my soul into peace.

XI.

Item, In virtue of this present writing, I John Shakspear do likewise most willingly and with all humility constitute and ordaine my good Angel, for Defender and Protectour of my soul in the dreadfull day of Judgement, when the finall sentance of eternall life or death shall be discussed and given; beseeching him, that, as my soule was appointed to his custody and protection when I lived, even so he will vouchsafe to defend the same at that houre, and conduct it to eternall bliss.

XII.

Item, I John Shakspear do in like manner pray and beseech all my dear friends, parents, and kinsfolks, by the bowels of our Saviour jesus Christ, that since it is uncertain what lot will befall me, for fear notwithstanding least by reason of my sinnes I be to pass and stay a long while in purgatory, they will vouchsafe to assist and succour me with their holy prayers and satisfactory workes, especially with the holy sacrifice of the masse, as being the most effectuall meanes to deliver soules from their torments and paines; from the which, if I shall by gods gracious goodnesse and by their vertuous workes be delivered, I do promise that I will not be ungratefull unto them, for so great a benefitt.

XIII.

Item, I John Shakspear doe by this my last will and testament bequeath my soul, as soon as it shall be delivered and loosened from the prison of this my body, to be entombed in the sweet and amorous coffin of the side of jesus Christ; and that in this life-giveing sepulcher it may rest and live, perpetually inclosed in that eternall habitation of repose, there to blesse for ever and ever that direfull iron of the launce, which, like a charge in a censore, formes so sweet and pleasant a monument within the sacred breast of my lord and saviour.

XIV.

Item, lastly I John Shakspear doe protest, that I will willingly accept of death in what manner soever it may befall me, conforming my will unto the will of god; accepting of the same in satisfaction for my sinnes, and giveing thanks unto his divine majesty for the life he hath bestowed upon me. And if it please him to prolong or shorten the same, blessed be he also a thousand thousand times; into whose most holy hands I commend my soul and body, my life and death: and I beseech him above all things, that he never permit any change to be made by me John Shakspear of this my aforesaid will and testament. Amen.

I John Shakspear have made this present writing of protestation, confession, and charter, in presence of the blessed virgin mary, my Angell guardian, and all the Celestiall Court, as witnesses hereunto: the which my meaning is, that it be of full value now presently and for ever, with the force and vertue of testament, codicill, and donation in cause of death; confirming it anew, being in perfect health of soul and body, and signed with mine own hand; carrying also the same about me; and for the better declaration hereof, my will and intention is that it be finally buried with me after my death.

Pater noster, Ave maria, Credo.
Jesu, son of David, have mercy on me.
Amen.

Source: Malone, Plays and Poems, 1790, vol. 1 pt. 2, pp. 162 to 166 and 330 to 331 (Internet Archive OCR, checked against page images of pp. 162, 163 and 330); Halliwell-Phillipps, Outlines, 1889, vol. 2, pp. 399 to 404 (the Malone and Jordan letters). The name and the patron saint were the two fill-in blanks of the printed formulary. Everything else is boilerplate.

What the Testament now shows

Steggle’s two claims. First, date: the earliest known appearance of the text is Venice, 1613, in Pietro Bertano’s Thesoro della dottrina di Christo, ascribed to Silvestro Ferrari; then Venice 1616, Tournon 1619, Rome 1622, Turin 1627, the first English translation and first Borromeo attribution in 1635, Saint-Omer 1638, more than 25 editions in four languages by 1660 and at least 80 in all. A copy therefore cannot have been John’s, who died in 1601. Second, name: the document was written for a woman (a female patron saint, documented female users), “Joan” is often misread as “John”, widows often reverted to maiden names, and Joan Shakespeare Hart lived as a widow in the western Henley Street cottage, exactly where the booklet was found, from 1616 to 1646. Thurston had already suggested “Joan” in 1923 but assumed a girl.

Steggle does not claim Joan was definitely Catholic; her public record is Church of England throughout, and he says Catholic belief “is not out of the realm of possibility”. Joseph Pearce’s Catholic World Report essay of 26 April 2024 is the only substantive published dissent found. He praises the evidence as “exemplary”, objects that the absence of earlier surviving editions is not proof of absence, and points to a footnote on a manuscript dated 1560 that Steggle calls spurious without argument. No refereed rebuttal or endorsement was located in Shakespeare Quarterly, Shakespeare Survey, Notes and Queries or the TLS between mid-2025 and October 2026; the OUP page listed no citing articles. Absence of a rebuttal is absence of evidence found, not proof none exists.

The strongest honest sentence this document now supports: a member of the Shakespeare household in the Birthplace, probably Joan Hart in the 1630s or 1640s, possessed a Catholic will of the soul.

Sources: Steggle, Shakespeare Quarterly 75.1 (2024), Oxford Academic; Steggle 2024 (PDF mirror); Bristol release; Pearce 2024; Wikipedia, Joan Shakespeare; Folger blog, December 2025.

Document B. The 1592 certificate for Stratford

Drawn up at Warwick on 25 September 1592 by the Warwickshire commissioners, answering Privy Council letters of 13 August 1592. The National Archives, SP 12/243/76. The Stratford entries, as transcribed in English Historical Documents from Fripp.

Page 167 of Peel's 1915 edition of the Seconde Parte of a Register, listing Warwickshire clergy in 1586, including John Frith of Grafton, an old priest and unsound in religion.
Peel, The Seconde Parte of a Register, 1915, page 167: the 1586 Puritan survey entry for Grafton, John Frith, an old priest and unsound in religion.Albert Peel (editor), 1915. Internet Archive. Public domain.
  • Wilful recusants still indictedFrances Jeffreyes (wife of John Jeffreyes, gent.), Richard Dibdale, Richard Joanes.
  • Suspected seminary priest or JesuitGeorge Coocke alias Cawdrey, whereabouts unknown.
  • Nine who do not come to churchMr John Wheeler, John Wheeler his son, Mr John Shakespeare, Mr Nicholas Barneshurste, Thomas James, William Bainton, Richard Harrington, William Fluellen, and George Bardolfe. “It is said that these last nine come not to church for fear of process for debt.”
  • Excused by age or infirmityMistress Geffreyes (widow), Mistress Barber, Julian Coorte, Griffen ap Robertes (dead), Joan Welche, Mistress Wheeler (conformed).
  • Conformed or promised toSixteen, including Joane Cooke alias Cawdrey, Alice Cooke, Thomas Reynoldes gent. and his wife, John Lane the elder; Mistress Clopton (widow of William Clopton esq.) “mistaken” and now attending.
  • Other parishes on the same certificateIdlicote: William Underhill gent., not seen at church since burying his wife on 17 November 1590. Henley in Arden: Sir Robert Whateley, “an old massing priest”.

Source: EHD transcription, Warwick University seminar PDF; Shakespeare Documented, SP 12/243/76 (“for feare of processe for debtte”). Fluellen and Bardolph on the same list as Shakespeare’s father is a real coincidence that no fetched source proves he used. Whether “fear of process for debt” appears as a formula in other counties’ 1592 returns was not resolved.

Document C. The Davies note

Written by Richard Davies into William Fulman’s blank Shakespeare entry, Corpus Christi College, Oxford, after 1688. Wording as quoted in the sources reached; the shelfmark and exact spelling were not checked against the manuscript for this file.

Shakespeare “was much given to all unluckiness in stealing venison and rabbits, particularly from Sir [blank] Lucy who oft had him whipped and sometimes imprisoned and at last made him fly his native country to his great advancement”. Lucy’s revenge was such that “he is his Justice Clodpate”, and, in allusion to his name, bore “three louses rampant for his Arms”. The note gives the death date, 23 April 1616, says he was buried at Stratford under a monument with a heavy curse on anyone who should move his bones, and ends:

“He dyed a papist.”

Sources: Shakespeare Documented, Henry Jackson letter (Fulman MS 304); Wikipedia, Thomas Lucy; Collins, Baptist Quarterly 1945; Catholic Encyclopedia 1912 (which spells it “Papyst”).

Dugdale's 1656 engraving of the Shakespeare monument in Holy Trinity, with the epitaph and the grave curse written out beside it.
The Shakespeare monument as engraved for Sir William Dugdale’s Antiquities of Warwickshire, 1656, the earliest printed picture of it; the lower part of a plate that also shows the Clopton tomb.Wenceslaus Hollar, for Sir William Dugdale's Antiquities of Warwickshire, 1656. Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.
The Elizabethan brick gatehouse of Charlecote Park, Warwickshire, with two octagonal turrets.
The gatehouse of Charlecote Park, Sir Thomas Lucy’s house. Lucy searched the Arden houses in 1583; the deer-poaching story in Davies’s note is set here.DeFacto, 2016-04-09. Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 4.0.